MountainViews
Welcome to MountainViews
If you want to use the website often please enrol (quick and free) at top right.

General Whatever you want to say that doesn't fit under the comments about places or another forum.
Sort by >

More controls

<< Prev page 1 .. 141 142 143 144 145 146 .. 393 Next page >>
Post details Post   (Contract pics)
You can count me i.. by kissanepat1   (Show all posts)
Hi Conor. The 8th .. by wicklore   (Show all posts)
Conor, Sharron and.. by mcrtchly   (Show all posts)
If you have an int.. by Trailtrekker   (Show all posts)
Anybody walking th.. by brenno   (Show all posts)
Not arranged yet, .. by Conor74   (Show all posts)
PLEASE STOP SPREAD.. by Conor74   (Show all posts)
simon3
2012-07-30 08:09:15
"Celebrating Croagh Patrick as it is." from simon3 Contract pics
Picture: Celebrating Croagh Patrick as it is. (Contract pics)

Heli-pad on Croagh Patrick
I heard about the helipad proposal this morning 30 Jul 2012 on RTE.
Supposedly it would be to airlift casualties from the top. However from the programme I gather Mayo Mountain Rescue has come out against. While I haven't seen their statement, with a moment's consideration it is possible to see obvious difficulties with the helipad for rescue. How many accidents actually occur on or near to the top? Surely most occur on the steep ground often some distance from the summit area. So in a rescue using the helipad the unwell and often unfit victim has first to get to the top. And this could be a climb of hundreds of slippery metres and extremely difficult. And frequently the top is covered with mist and extremely cold anyway something we saw the time we were with Matt Loughrey as he completed his 365 summit ascents last year.

No, the helipad would be almost useless for mountain rescue. But, folks, what would it be ideal for? Helicopter trips by sightseers to the top of course. See the historic view over Clew Bay! Only Euro 199 (just 299 if you weigh over 250 lb) Go in style. See Ireland from the air, the high point of your visit. Drink in the peace and tranquility and stunning views (as you shatter them). Bring your child after first communion. Celebrate YOUR marriage on the Reek. Think of the local jobs angle also.

Karl Boyle chief officer of Mountaineering Ireland did his affable and informed best to counter the proposal on RTE. Actually, too affable at first until the presenter reminded him he was here to oppose the thing. But he settled down and made the points systematically. He was lucky because the proponent of the helipad became incommunicado so Karl could further develop his case which he did including mentioning that an assessment had been done of the place and MI are hosting a conference "Helping the Hills" which this website has already promoted.

However for my money in a contest between local enterprise with all sorts of fake suggestions like "aiding mountain rescue" and MI, the outcome may not be too clear cut. Why? Because it smacks of An Taisce versus Jackie Healy-Rae. Or an east coast elite versus the local people who will be sold on employment or whatever.

Mountaineering Ireland has created and fulfilled a role in insurance, training and activity regulation but has yet to achieve much in sport development (except for climbing) or inspiration. It sat on the sidelines and pontificated about challenge walks for a decade and currently does much the same for charity walks. It needs to learn to capture the imagination of walkers and local communities with sport initiatives. And ditch the name. If 90% of your actual or potential members are solely hillwalkers then this must be reflected in your name. If you want to address national issues on mountains, the name needs to be immediately relevant and symbolise a non-elitist approach to the audience.

So, right with MI for opposing the helipad. And I hope that many regulars to this website will back that. But shouldn't MI reflect on its stance.

Photo: Celebrating Croagh Patrick from its East Top, June 2011. There were hundreds of people on the Reek that day but could any of them really rely on a helicopter rescue given the mist?
On the topic of wh.. by jackill   (Show all posts)
Vertigo has a Dali.. by CaptainVertigo   (Show all posts)


RECENT CONTRIBUTIONS 1 2 3 .. 23 Next page >>
Summit Comment
Slieve Bawn: No longer a drive-up
TommyMc less than an hour ago.
A series of new road barriers means that it's no longer possible to drive further than the car park on the Strokestown side. A very pleasant walk uphill from the car park to the summit and back to...

  
Summit Comment
Mangerton North Top: On the way to Mangerton
MountainHunter 8 hours ago.
I started at Point A car park and followed the path. At about 520m (-9.4817 51.9882) the path swings westward, as you walk along the path, the coum for the Devil's Punchbowl comes into view. After...

  
Summit Comment
Knockalongy South-West Top: Choose your highest point
madfrankie 10 hours ago.
Whichever turfy outcrop is the highest point now may not be in 10 years time.

Summit Comment
Knockalongy South-West Top: Beware of the barrier
madfrankie 10 hours ago.
We followed sandman's route to the summit which is probably the best way to explore Knockalongy and its satellites. Gentle gradients but many eroded peat hags. Worth noting that the forest barrier...

  
Track
Kate's to John's - Na Sléibhte Club Walk
GSheehy a day ago.
When we set up the club we said it was all about the economics of supply and demand - if we supplied challenging walk... walk, Len: 24.9km, Climb: 2015m, Area: Tomies North Top, Purple Mountain (Irel

  
Track
Carrauntoohil via the 'Back Ladder' from the Bridia Valley
peter1 2 days ago.
Park at a small turning place, just opposite The Stepping Stone / Cooky Monsters accommodation and cafe.The route fol... walk, Len: 11.5km, Climb: 1097m, Area: Carrauntoohil, MacGillycuddy's Reeks (I

Summit Comment
Mweelrea: Coastal mountains
simon3 3 days ago.
Ben Bury and Mweelrea form an impressive sight from Clare Island.

  
Summit Comment
Caherbarnagh East Top: An unremarkable summit, worth the visit for the views.
David-Guenot 6 days ago.
The summit is unremarkable though easy to spot as it lies along the fence.

  
Summit Comment
Caherbarnagh East Top: An easy stroll from Caherbarnagh.
David-Guenot 6 days ago.
There is a gate to cross when coming down from the cairn at the NE end of the main Caherbarnagh ridge (I found it was actually easier to cross the fence just right of the gate). There is a faint t...

Summit Comment
Binn Bhriocáin: Long views of a stepped descent.
simon3 3 days ago.
Letterbreckaun can be seen from Clare island, around 33km away. It appears between Mweelrea and the high ground towards the Sheefrys.

  
Summit Comment
Caherbarnagh East Top: A worthwhile addition.
David-Guenot 6 days ago.
This summit is easily reached from the main Caherbarnagh ridge and seems easy enough to get to from Curracahill as well. If coming from Caherbarnagh, best is to cross the fence just before the col...

  
Summit Comment
The Paps East: Two shapely hills.
TommyV a week ago.
There is a forestry road in the Clydagh Valley with parking at W12955 83343. Following this road will lead you out onto the open mountain. From here it's a steep pull up to spot height 562 metres ...


RECENT CONTRIBUTIONS 1 2 3 .. 23 Next page >>