Welcome to "MountainViews" Guest visitor - have a look around -
enrol (free & quick) to see Lists & Logs etc.
| Post details |
Post (Expand pics) |
simon3
2012-05-01 16:10:11 |
Re Hiding the Hills
Context of comment:Dessie1
The Highest 100 list doesn't contain any Munros. The Munros are specifically a list of 3000 ft Scottish mountains created by Sir Hugh Munro in 1891. We do have a list of 900s which for Ireland happens to be the same list as the list of 3000 footers. Message:The reason for not including all the 900s is that some of the 900s while they have height have little else. For example if you list all summits by height you will include say the two Knockbrinneas, which are little more than a spur of Beenkeragh, or Carrignabinnia which is a bump on the Galty ridge, or Ben Bury which is a bump between the brilliant Mweelrea and the exciting Ben Lugmores.
So it was decided to set the prominence requirement for the 100 Highest some years ago to 100m This means that anything included must look like an independent summit not a subsidiary peak. It also has the serious advantage of increasing the number of mountain areas containing a "Highest 100" from 21 to 33 so that they are spread more evenly over the island.
All lists are compromises however overall we reckon this is the best balance. |
| Context of comment: (Show all posts) |
| Context of comment: (Show all posts) |
| Context of comment: (Show all posts) |
| Context of comment: (Show all posts) |
| Context of comment: (Show all posts) |
| Context of comment: (Show all posts) |
| Context of comment: (Show all posts) |
| Context of comment: (Show all posts) |
| Context of comment: (Show all posts) |
|
|
|
|
Summit Summary Knockane: Easy though rough to get to, great views. |
Collaborative entry Last edit by: simon3 15 hours ago. Park at a forest entrance R850 665 , room for 5 cars, walk into the forest right at R844 663 which will bring you through the forest onto moorland. As it peters out you have a rough 200 meter cros... |
|
Track Simple way up from the SW. |
simon3 15 hours ago. Park near the start off the road which was retarred in 2012. walk, Length:2.8km, Climb: 152m, Area: Knockadigeen Hill, Shannon (Ireland) Knockadigeen |
|
|
Summit Summary Cooneen Hill: Briars, pines and pain |
Collaborative entry Last edit by: simon3 15 hours ago. Start from the forestry entrance at R90294 66782 and walk uphill, taking two lefts and one right off the main track onto a very rough track thats almost blocked near the end with felled trees, to... |
|
|
Forum: General Thank you MV |
ahendroff 2 days ago. At 5.42pm today I completed my 404th and final Arderin. Long journey to here. Delighted & overjoyed. Humbled at the challenge also. And thanks Mountain Views for that. Gougane Barra will always be... |
|
Forum: General ... |
BleckCra 3 days ago. Thank you kevin carroll. If I can put a smile on that contrary face, the Matterhorn should be a cakewalk. |
|
|
|
|
|
Forum: Suggestions Re Main Area Display, logging |
simon3 3 days ago. The suggestion is that the list of summits for a mountain area obtained by asking for More Detail for the mountain area show whether or not the summit has been climbed. This has now been implement... |
|
|
Summit Comment Soarns Hill: Forested summit |
slemish 2 days ago. Getting to the summit of Soarns Hill is difficult and the extensive forestry means that views are severely limited. But as it qualifies under MV prominence rules, off I went to climb it. I parked ... |
|
|
|