Welcome to MountainViews
If you want to use the website often please enrol (quick and free) at top right.

Site Feedback Site announcements, requests for features, bug reports about the software of the service.
Sort by >

More controls

<< Prev page 1 .. 25 26 27 28 29 30 .. 38 Next page >>
Post details Post   (Expand pics)
Context of comment:   (Show all posts)
Context of comment:   (Show all posts)
wicklore
2010-07-28 23:43:13
Re: Knockeirky
Context of comment:Sufficient prominence to be included on MV list?
Message:Hi Conor74. Your query re: Knockeirky rang a bell for me. I checked some old material I had from when I assisted in establishing the prominence of the hills and mountains on MountainViews. I see where I wrote a note on my paperwork as follows: 'Possible new summit. Knockeirky, Map 85, grid ref: V852 558. 577m. Prominence 32m?'

When viewed on the map, the col between Knockeirky and its nearest higher neighbour, Cushnaficulla, can be given a height of 545m. (based on finding the average between the 540m and 550m contour lines which is where the col lies). This average col height would give Knockeirky a prominence of 32 metres and a place on the MountainViews list. (It would need a prominence of 30 metres to be included). I believe that Knockeirky DOES qualify to be listed as a MountainViews summit.

However the col could be as high as 549 metres in height, giving Knockeirky a prominence of 28 metres which is 2 metres below the criteria to be listed as a summit. (I am just the bearer of the news about MountainViews stringent criteria - I don't want to be held accountable for this strict mathemtical rule!)

Therefore what is needed is for intrepid MountainViewers to climb the mountain and record the height of the col! We can then work out the prominence for sure and harangue Simon to add it to the list! (ps- you mentioned someone had recorded the col height already. Would they contribute to this discussion?
Context of comment:   (Show all posts)
Context of comment:   (Show all posts)
Context of comment:   (Show all posts)
Context of comment:   (Show all posts)
Context of comment:   (Show all posts)
Context of comment:   (Show all posts)
Context of comment:   (Show all posts)


RECENT CONTRIBUTIONS 1 2 3 .. 18 Next page >>
Forum: General
Walker's €40k claim against NPWS overturned i
brenno 2 days ago.
Great news from High Court as that €40k ruling in favour of that walker who tripped on the Wicklow Way boardwalk near the JB Malone memorial overturned in High Court. We can all toast Judge White ...

  
Track
Sugar Loaf Circular
tommyclarke 4 days ago.
walk, Len: 5.4km, Climb: 404m, Area: Great Sugar Loaf, Dublin/Wicklow (Ireland)...

  
Summit Comment
Sgurr Thuilm: If Allt a' Choire Charnaig in spate there's a small footbridge u
melohara a week ago.
If the Allt a' Choire Charnaig is in spate there is a small footbridge, wires and planks, a little upstream

Summit Comment
Sgurr nan Coireachan: If Allt a' Choire Charnaig in spate there's a small foot
melohara a week ago.
If the Allt a' Choire Charnaig is in spate there is a small footbridge, wires and planks, a little upstream

  
Track
Near Church Mountain, Dublin/Wicklow (Ireland)
Bunsen7 5 days ago.
Took this track to bag Church Mountian and then Corriebracks on a cold wet winter afternoon. Visibility was poor high... walk, Len: 11.0km, Climb: 603m, Area: Church Mountain, Dublin/Wicklow (Ireland

  
Summit Comment
The Big Gun: A Big View
mcrtchly a week ago.
A view of the Big Gun, Cnoc na Péiste and the southern ridge of the Reeks taken after a light fall of snow in late January 2017

Summit Comment
Sgurr a'Choire Riabhaich: If Allt a' Choire Charnaig in spate there's a small
melohara a week ago.
If the Allt a' Choire Charnaig is in spate there is a small footbridge, wires and planks, a little upstream

  
Summit Comment
Tievebaun: Crash of 42-31420 in 1943
dp_burke 2 weeks ago.
Just a quick link to the story of 42-31420's crash on Tievebaun as I found it.http://www.ww2irishaviation.com/42-31420.htmIf you do go up top the small bit of wreckage that is left, please don't r...

  
Summit Comment
Slievenaglogh: Interesting views from a minor summit.
simon3 2 weeks ago.
While it's never going to be hard to climb a 310m hill, this one does put up something of a fight when approaching it from the North, with defenses of mush rush, barbed gorse and little tracks.The...

Track
A Birthday Walk in Joyce Country
GSheehy 6 days ago.
?Enjoy your day on the mountain tomorrow, a fabulous way to start ones 52nd year on the Earth.? That was the text me walk, Len: 39.3km, Climb: 2087m, Area: Devilsmother South Top, Partry/Joyce Co

  
Summit Comment
Lannimore Hill: A nice walk
Wilderness 2 weeks ago.
You can park at the south side of Lannimore Hill ; close to where the Ballinlea and Maghery roads meet: D042426. Wanting to do a longer walk I parked at Ballintoy and walked the wildest way up ,(...

  
Forum: General
Reforestation row in Scotland
Aidy 3 days ago.
An interesting brewing row in Scotland where Mountaineering Scotland have allied themselves with The Scottish Gamekeepers Association in concerns about reforestation. https://www.theguardian.com/u...


RECENT CONTRIBUTIONS 1 2 3 .. 18 Next page >>