Welcome to MountainViews
If you want to use the website often please enrol (quick and free) at top right.

General Whatever you want to say that doesn't fit under the comments about mountains or another forum.
Sort by >

More controls

<< Prev page 1 .. 12 13 14 15 16 17 .. 368 Next page >>
Post details Post   (Expand pics)
tamjk
2015-09-02 17:17:42
OSI Perspectives . . . .
Wicklore,

I realise that the phrasing I used was ambiguous but I did not mean to suggest that MountainViews was a representative organization for climbers. By "other representative organization" I had in mind Mountaineering Ireland and its larger local climbing clubs.
Last year when I made a congratulatory email to OSI on publication of their 1:25,000 maps, I expressed a wish that they cover more of the other mountain ranges of Kerry & Cork like Brandon Mts, Slieve Mish range, Caha/Sugarloaf, etc. I also expressed a hope that safe summit routes would be added to these maps to prevent the annual loss of young adults on these mountains since it seemed to me - moreover on reading inquest reports on climbing falls - that many climbers simply set out on their last climb without a clear idea of their chosen route and its risks.
My respondent replied that he largely agreed with these sentiments but had not been able to identify any single authority responsible for selecting such routes. My own experience when discussing the matter with personnel in MI, KMR, etc has been similar. MI : "support services to members only"; KMR : "rescue & recovery only."
On the matter of 1:25,000 map production itself - regardless of mountain route inclusion - he offered production cost and uncertainty of market as reasons for not rolling out more than 3 of these maps "pending the introduction of new technology".

It's hard not to get the feeling that a sort of machismo montañero exists among the management of climbing organizations. A simple analysis of the routes most frequently associated with rescue operations should tell which routes are definitely NOT for day-trippers. While most of us have different climbing difficulty issues - and for sure different fear issues - I think we can all see that certain routes are clearly dangerous for people just looking for a day out.

As regards the 1:25,000 maps themselves, I no longer believe that OSI has a serious data, processing or production cost problem with making these.
What they do have - or so imagine - is a "pension fund deficit" problem.
Look at the accounts for OSI (you'll get them in the Annual Report on their website) and you'll see a rare bird.
You'll see Pension Fund entries figure prominently not just as a footnote to the Balance Sheet but bang in the middle of their Income Statement, BS and other financial statements.
I'm no accountant but I would have thought that whatever the pension liabilities of OSI may be, it ought hardly be allowed to restrict the investment needed to maintain their raison-d'etre activities. If nothing else, selling maps to walkers, bikers, climbers and tourists might be the only way by which they can ever clear their pension fund shortfall.
But OSI seems heading for the ultimate stop on the Bureaucratic Absurdity Line : its primary purpose being to provide a comfortable income to its present and past functionaries.
The much-vaunted digital map offering cost €48 for an A4 size and around €70 for an A3 size is hardly a plausible alternative for ordinary climbers, walkers and bikers. After all that you have the cost of printing them.
I'm told that a Cambridge company has been given rights to use OSI map data in their app (Viewranger) for people doing routes. But the maximum resolution is poor and the actual map images look oldish. The peak-names cover much of the peak contours and increase in size as the resolution increases, which makes the estimation of cross-sections and gradients awkward. No way is it a viable alternative to a hard-copy high-res map.
So there we are climbing in Ireland - on our own and without a proper map to guide us !

@ Mcrtchly,

If the 'Sirrah' term offended you, I apologize.
I used it in its dramatic sense. I make no claim on superiority of any kind on you.
As to the 1:25,000 map, all i can say is that i looked at the Killarney National Park Adventure map yesterday and it seemed to run no further west than the mountain range just east of the Mullaghanattin Horseshoe.
But you are the expert in this and I accept your statement that the Mullaghanattin Horseshoe is covered here.
But I do not accept that OSI correctly judges the market for these maps as inadequate to produce more than 3 of them.
I don't say that ALL the country need be covered. Just those areas with sufficient detail and demand. I think that Slieve Mish and Caha fall into this category, as do other areas in this country.
In reply to Tamjk'.. by mcrtchly   (Show all posts)
Addressing someone.. by kernowclimber   (Show all posts)
Hi tamjk. In your .. by wicklore   (Show all posts)
** The OSI public .. by tamjk   (Show all posts)
Those who keep a s.. by Onzy   (Show all posts)
Go to this webpage.. by tamjk   (Show all posts)
In reply to a rece.. by mcrtchly   (Show all posts)
The Tasermiut rang.. by kernowclimber   (Show all posts)
Most of Texas is a.. by Colin Murphy   (Show all posts)


RECENT CONTRIBUTIONS 1 2 3 .. 18 Next page >>
Summit Comment
Arderin: First and Last CHP for 2016
paddyobpc 17 hours ago.
Walk Date: 17 Apr 2016. Dillon(dillonkdy) and I resumed our CHP challenge for 2016 on Arderin on a cool dry April Sunday. We were now armed with Kieron Gribbon’s book “Ireland's County High Points...

  
Summit Comment
Moylussa: Last CHP of 2015
paddyobpc 17 hours ago.
Walk Date: 06 Sep 2015. Our last CHP of the year was Moylussa in Clare and again it was Rachel, Dillon(dillonkdy) and myself on the walk. Blessed again with good weather the views of Lough Derg as...

  
Summit Comment
Carrauntoohil: with Dillon and Rachel
paddyobpc 17 hours ago.
Walk Date: 18 Aug 2015. We were waiting for a good time to tackle Carrauntoohil and finally a suitable day arrived. Rachel, Dillon(dillonkdy) and myself set off from the Hydro Track Carpark around...

Track
Near Mount Corrin, Mizen/Sheeps Head (Ireland)
Eirepur 20 hours ago.
walk, Len: 2.2km, Climb: 140m, Area: Mount Corrin, Mizen/Sheeps Head (Ireland) ...

  
Summit Comment
Knockmealdown: for gribboneer-of-the-year
paddyobpc 17 hours ago.
In December of 2016 while earning points for gribboneer-of-the-year http://www.highpointireland.com/gribboneer-of-the-year.html we returned to Knockmealdown on two occasions. The first was on Satu...

  
Forum: General
Irish hill runners and the Spine Race
IainT a day ago.
The Spine Race is a 268 mile run up the Pennine Way in the north of England, run every January, invariably featuring snowdrifts, gales and many miles of sucking bog, much of it run in the dark. It...

Summit Comment
Knockmealdown: My nearest CHP
paddyobpc 17 hours ago.
Walk Date: 01 Aug 2015. I have had many walks to Knockmealdown previously, with various start points, Baylough Car Park, The Vee, even from home in Gurtacullen in the shadow of the Vee at one time...

  
Track
Near The Paps East, Paps/Derrynasaggart (Ireland)
Eirepur 22 hours ago.
walk, Len: 9.4km, Climb: 676m, Area: The Paps East, Paps/Derrynasaggart (Irelan...

  
Summit Comment
Kippure: “Military Road”
paddyobpc 17 hours ago.
Walk Date: 25 Jul 2015. Myself and my son Dillon(dillonkdy) were in Dublin and free for the evening while others went to see Ed Sheerin so we decided to climb Kippure and knock another CHP off the...

Summit Comment
Lugnaquilla: from Glenmalure
paddyobpc 17 hours ago.
Walk Date: 23 Jul 2015. I had walked Lugnaquilla previously in 2011 from near the Glenmalure Hostel returning into the Glenmalure valley via the zig zags and walking the road back up to the car. T...

  
Summit Comment
Knockboy: The start of a CHP Challenge
paddyobpc 18 hours ago.
Walk Date: 26 Jun 2015. It was during a search for mountains to climb while on a break in the Schull area that I learned that Knockboy was the highest point in Cork. My daughter Rachel and son Dil...

  
Track
Near Mount Gabriel, Mizen/Sheeps Head (Ireland)
Eirepur 22 hours ago.
walk, Len: 5.9km, Climb: 290m, Area: Mount Gabriel, Mizen/Sheeps Head (Ireland)...


RECENT CONTRIBUTIONS 1 2 3 .. 18 Next page >>