Welcome to MountainViews
If you want to use the website often please enrol (quick and free) at top right.

General Whatever you want to say that doesn't fit under the comments about places or another forum.
Sort by >

More controls

<< Prev page 1 .. 17 18 19 20 21 22 .. 373 Next page >>
Post details Post   (Expand pics)
Hi TamI don't know.. by Peter Walker   (Show all posts)
Wicklore,I realise.. by tamjk   (Show all posts)
In reply to Tamjk'.. by mcrtchly   (Show all posts)
Addressing someone.. by kernowclimber   (Show all posts)
wicklore
2015-09-02 14:59:13
MV doesn't support 1:25 000 maps?
Hi tamjk. In your post re mapping (which I'll leave to mcrtchly and other mapping experts to answer) you also made the comment that:

"And, from what I hear at the OSI, no one from Mountain View or any other representative organization for climbing has pushed very much for their publication (1:25 000 maps) despite the obvious advantages"

This came as a severe shock to me because I must therefore have entirely dreamed about helping to represent MountainViews at various OSI consultations which we were specifically invited to, where we discussed their 1:25 000 maps in detail, proposed new areas for 1:25 000 mapping and reviewed the new 1:25 000 maps as they went through production. We recommended areas for improvement/ inclusion and pushed for better quality mapping with more accurate features, such as contour lines, forest tracks, fences, place names etc. When I say we attended consultations, there were perhaps three organisations in attendance, as invited by OSI. If you have a contact in OSI who is telling you we are not pushing for their publication they are completely wrong as we have played an important role in advising and supporting the publication of 1:25 000 maps. Our main criteria is that they should be a true and accurate reflection of what is on the ground. If there is any doubt about our importance to OSI just look for the MountainViews logo on the back of the OSI 1:25 00 maps. Please tell your contact at OSI that we are puzzled by their views and would like further information.

The issues you raise in your various posts are very interesting and need debate, but it doesn't help when wrong facts are thrown in. For example MountainViews is not a representative body for climbing. That job (and government funding) goes to Mountaineering Ireland, who have also liaised with OSI on their mapping.

Tamjk, one of the purposes of MountainViews is to give members the opportunity to write, (subjectively) about their experience in the hills and mountains. We also have a Short Summary section which aims to provide short, factual data such as parking places, landmarks etc. I have always found that I am different from every other walker, and that what they find easy I find hard, what takes them 1 hour takes me two, what they say is ‘a bit of a climb’ is a daunting scramble for me. I’ve turned back on several occasions as I don’t have the energy, the nerve or the gear to go on. But on other occasions I’ve done routes that others think are a bit crazy – my forest-bashing exploits are well documented in my summit comments!

The point I’m making is that each to his/her own ability – the beauty of this site is that it allows people express their experience in the hills, but that it must be filtered through the expertise that person has. Conor74, for example, is an athlete who engages in marathons and mountain running, so when I see him write that he can complete Mullaghanattin in a few hours, one look at the map, the contours and terrain tells me it will take me several more hours. What we need is more ordinary Joe Soaps writing about their experiences to give a broader view of a summits’ challenge, but as a voluntary community website it’s up to individuals to make that effort.

Finally, you asked in a previous post how to add a comment to this Motley Views Forum? – go into Motley Views and scroll down to the bottom of the comments for that page. There is a box that says ‘Add to General’. Click on that and you’ll be able to add a comment.
** The OSI public .. by tamjk   (Show all posts)
Those who keep a s.. by Onzy   (Show all posts)
Go to this webpage.. by tamjk   (Show all posts)
In reply to a rece.. by mcrtchly   (Show all posts)
The Tasermiut rang.. by kernowclimber   (Show all posts)


RECENT CONTRIBUTIONS 1 2 3 .. 25 Next page >>
Track
The Sturrall
Peter Walker 18 hours ago.
walk, Len: 9.1km, Climb: 268m, Area: Donegal Islands (Ireland)

  
Summit Comment
Great Saltee Island: Bird's Glare
simon3 19 hours ago.
. .

  
Summit Comment
Curra Hill: Cloudy Climb
andreos97 4 days ago.
Fantastic walk, personally feel it's best starting your approach from Glenbeigh village and heading up through the forest as it's quite well signposted. Once leaving the cover of the trees, we wer...

Track
Croaghavehy
Peter Walker 18 hours ago.
As prescribed by Mr Sandman. Parked at the Glengesh viewpoint (where I got to admire some quite astonishing car positi... walk, Len: 3.0km, Climb: 114m, Area: Croaghavehy, Donegal SW (Ireland) Croagh

  
Summit Comment
Cnoc Lios Uachtair: Connemara in the round
fieldoptic 5 days ago.
An easy to access and navigate hill, well worth it for its central position and views in every direction. Park as previously suggested at L8530 4820 and head north east before swinging north. The ...

  
Track
Awkward access to a small but rugged summit
madfrankie a day ago.
Despite it's modest 405m height, Croaghacullin is not the easiest hill to climb, or indeed to find. There may be other... walk, Len: 3.9km, Climb: 255m, Area: Croaghacullin, Donegal SW (Ireland) Croa

Summit Comment
Cnoc Mordáin: Long Connemara Summer Evening
fieldoptic 5 days ago.
Though the road near L88003920 appears unfenced you will encounter a fence very soon after leaving the road. This fence extends along this back road, Bothar na Scrathóg and keeps cattle in typical...

  
Track
Table Mountain Loop including the Air Crash Site from 1957
Tobi a day ago.
A beautiful loop walk taking in Sugarloaf, Lobawn, Table Mountain West Top and Table Mountain. From Table Mountain, in... walk, Len: 17.5km, Climb: 672m, Area: Sugarloaf, Dublin/Wicklow (Ireland) Sug

  
Forum: General
Object to very high windfarm in Sperrins?
simon3 2 days ago.
Mountaineering Ireland is considering submitting an objection to a revised application for the Doraville Wind Farm in the Sperrins, on the grounds of visual impact and detraction from the walking/...

Summit Comment
Ballinacorbeg: Worth a brief visit
Bunsen7 a week ago.
Pleasantly surprised by this, could clearly see Lugnaquilla and Croaghanmoira, as well as numerous other summits, slightly awkward entry into the fields just west of the forest which don't appear ...

  
Track
Corranabinnia Horseshoe
Peter Walker 3 days ago.
There are plenty of good reasons for the discerning hillwalker to make haste to the Nephin Beg range out in the west, ... walk, Len: 15.9km, Climb: 1028m, Area: Bengorm, North Mayo (Ireland) Bengorm,

  
Summit Comment
Ballinafunshoge: Eastern View
Bunsen7 a week ago.
Tree felling has opened up this view of the Vartry reservoir and the east coast from just below the summit of Ballinfunshoge. The Wicklow way runs left to right (southwards) just a few hundred met...


RECENT CONTRIBUTIONS 1 2 3 .. 25 Next page >>