Welcome to MountainViews
If you want to use the website often please enrol (quick and free) at top right.

General Whatever you want to say that doesn't fit under the comments about mountains or another forum.
Sort by >

More controls

<< Prev page 1 .. 159 160 161 162 163 164 .. 368 Next page >>
Post details Post   (Expand pics)
The best ones are .. by jackill   (Show all posts)
On the weekend of .. by gilnadowd   (Show all posts)
I was absolutely t.. by CaptainVertigo   (Show all posts)
...the times I got.. by Conor74   (Show all posts)
Dessie1 - no myste.. by slemish   (Show all posts)
CaptainVertigo if .. by slemish   (Show all posts)
Good news - Kelly .. by slemish   (Show all posts)
By the time we met.. by simon3   (Show all posts)
simon3
2011-09-21 13:34:49
That Errigal account - part 1.
Reading these accounts of near tragedy made me reflect on the times it has happened to me. I happened upon this account, reproduced with permission, from Richard Smith on newsgroup uk.walking.rec It's about the choices when one person's excessive ambition drags in another.

Richard Smith said:
"I've just been reminded of something that happened to me a few years ago on Liathach that I had all-but-forgotten. I'd be interested to know
what other people would have done in the same situation.

I was part of a group of four spending a few days in Torridon one August. We all knew each other well socially but had done relatively little walking together. On the first day we'd done Beinn Alligin over the Horns, and the second day was a traverse of the Beinn Eighe ridge, so by the third day when Liathach was suggested that seemed a reasonable suggestion.

The third day was a nice sunny August day with a light refreshing breeze -- ideal weather. We went up the steep path to Stob a' Choire Liath Mòr and followed the Liathach ridge westwards to Mullach an Rathain, negotiating the pinnacles along Am Fasarinen slowly but without incident. By now it was early afternoon and we stopped to admire the view from the summit.

We were talking about the various mountains we could see, and as some point somebody pointed to the northern ridge out to Meall Dearg. I said the ridge was called the Northern Pinnacles and that it was arguably the
hardest arête on the mainland. One of the group who I shall call James [not his real name] suggested we go out along it. I'd done it before so knew what it was like, and I was concerned that he was up to it so
quizzed him on what other similar things he'd done. His answers (Crib Goch, Tryfan north ridge, Striding Edge) made me think it would be overly ambitious, especially as we didn't have a rope.

James was quite persistent about wanting to do it; the other two, probably less experienced, were egging him on and were quite content to wait on the top in the sun while James and I went out and back. After a while I said I understood there to be a path a little way below the arête that avoided the worst step on the arête and that might offer a more suitable route out to Meall Dearg and back again. He said he it was the arête and Meall Dearg that he wanted to do. I told him I wasn't willing take him down the arête. "Fine," he said, "I'll do it by myself." I watched him start down the arête for long enough to be convinced he wasn't just calling my bluff.

I then chased after him, rather concerned for his safety. I'd done the route a year (maybe two) earlier and could more-or-less remember the line I'd taken, and from what he'd told me, I was fairly sure I had considerably more scrambling experience than he had. To start with I let James stay in front, hoping he might get to a bit he wasn't willing to lead down and turn back. We didn't.

The toughest bit of the route, in my opinion, is a bit where you have a choice between negotiating a sheer 8' drop onto a exposed ledge, perhaps 3' deep, and a steep 30' chimney packed with loose rock. (There may have been other possibilities that I hadn't found.) James had started down the chimney and seemed to be getting into difficulties -- unsurprisingly, as in my view the chimney was only suitable for ascent. I helped him back up, and then demonstrated how to get down the 8' drop, going first myself. (Basically, lower yourself over the edge until hanging from your fingers, and then drop the last 6" as there were no footholds to speak of.) At that point, I was committed to descending at least as far as the bottom of that pinnacle when I could get round to reascend the chimney.

James was very reluctant to continue (or go back, or anything else). I took a few minutes looking to see whether from below I could see an alternative route for him, but couldn't. The ledge he had to drop onto wasn't wide enough for me to stand behind him to prevent him from slipping backwards (not that that was actually very likely, but would probably have made it feel safer). I did in the end talk him down. After that, although the route was much easier, James was a nervous wreck and in quite a few places needed me underneath guiding his feet.

We did eventually get over to Meall Dearg without further incident; James (unsurprisingly) wasn't willing to go back up the ridge to rejoin the main group, so we decided to separate from them and drop down to the north. Fortunately we all had mobile phones and we were able to communicate this to the other half of the group who agreed to move the car to the Torridon House carpark where we would end up reaching the road.
One question I alw.. by Dessie1   (Show all posts)


RECENT CONTRIBUTIONS 1 2 3 .. 17 Next page >>
Track
Central Dingle Quartet from Anascaul
Bunsen7 22 hours ago.
Follow the track from Anascaul lake car park northwards up onto the mountain plateau.Track leads northwards from lake... walk, Len: 15.8km, Climb: 949m, Area: Stradbally Mountain, Central Dingle (Ire

  
Summit Summary
Seefin Mountain W Top: Bog and rough ground.
Collaborative entry Last edit by: melohara 2 days ago.
Car park space at R66276 16811. Over or around the gate and head uphill on a good track that crosses the hill near the summit of Seefin Mountain East top.Follow the track on downhill from the cres...

  
Track
Pic du Midi d'Ossau
David-Guenot a day ago.
The idea came from my 60-year-old, freshly retired neighbour, as we and some other members of the local badminton club m walk, Len: 16.2km, Climb: 1353m, Area: France, Nouvelle-Aquitaine ()

Summit Summary
Seefin Mountain E Top: Up the old bog road.
Collaborative entry Last edit by: melohara 2 days ago.
Car park space at R66276 16811. Over or around the gate and head uphill on a good track that crosses the hill near the summit.On the crest of the hill the summit cairn is over a wall to your right...

  
Summit Summary
Seefin South-East Top: Seefin South East Top is easily visited
Collaborative entry Last edit by: melohara 2 days ago.
Seefin South East Top is easily visited from the track leading to Seefin Mountain East Top and Seefin Mountain West Top which starts st R66276 16811. Just follow the track to R65202 17892 from whe...

  
Summit Comment
Carnaween: The visitors book box near the summit
Aidy 6 days ago.
Just wanted to show the brilliantly constructed little box which contains the visitors book. It was too wet and windy on my visit to take it out and risk ruining it. A few shafts of light breaking...

Summit Comment
Carnaween: Bad Weather Adding Drama To Great Views
Aidy 6 days ago.
I used the commonly taken route from Disert Graveyard (worth a visit in its own right) over ground that was alternatively boggy or pretty steep. It was freezing cold in these parts, with a strong ...

  
Track
Pic Rouge de Bassiès
David-Guenot 2 days ago.
This was the first of the two big hikes I did in the Pyrenees in summer 2016. Hiking in the summer often means a sunny d walk, Len: 16.3km, Climb: 1342m, Area: France, Midi-Pyr?n?es ()

  
Summit Comment
Corrin: A family stroll.
David-Guenot a week ago.
Climbed this hill in November 2014, with a friend who used to live in the area. Starting at the Coillte car park, we did a nice loop on the forest paths, circling around the hill in an anticlockwi...

Forum: General
MV Mountain Gathering 2017
Onzy 4 days ago.
Always a great night ... all welcome.

  
Summit Comment
Luggala: Fancy View from White Hill
davsheen 2 weeks ago.
Autumn's evening view across to Luggala/Fancy from White Hill on route down from Djouce using the Wicklow Way boardwalk section.

  
Summit Comment
Binn Charrach: The peat-hag capital of Connemara
markwallace 2 weeks ago.
The descent from Benbaun to the R344 via Knockpasheemore/Binn Charrach is hard going after a day in the Bens. The Knockpasheemore ridge looks nice and flat from below, but is boggy, undulating and...


RECENT CONTRIBUTIONS 1 2 3 .. 17 Next page >>