Welcome to MountainViews
If you want to use the website often please enrol (quick and free) at top right.

General Whatever you want to say that doesn't fit under the comments about mountains or another forum.
Sort by >

More controls

<< Prev page 1 .. 251 252 253 254 255 256 .. 368 Next page >>
Post details Post   (Expand pics)
Yes, Mark, I came .. by weedavie   (Show all posts)
I climbed this sur.. by dr_banuska   (Show all posts)
Emerald Island GPS.. by Pazapas   (Show all posts)
I am an androgenic.. by CaptainVertigo   (Show all posts)
am i blind/stupid .. by markmjcampion   (Show all posts)
Yes marymac: erudi.. by Bleck Cra   (Show all posts)
Valentinesís Day. .. by Bleck Cra   (Show all posts)
To have great poet.. by marymac   (Show all posts)
simon3
2010-02-11 20:51:45
Re A Logic of Difference
Yes, I think a case can definitely be made for Bray Head and hundreds of other places, particularly round the coast., but lets back off a bit. MountainViews is doing two different things. One is to list summits with a view to providing a space for comments and culture on them etc and secondly to provide challenge agendas, by way of specific lists such as say the County Highest points or the Arderins. In the past and to an extent these two functions were less distinct however with the creation and codification of various lists, this frees one function from the other.

Or in other words, we can increase the number of summits without it affecting the various challenges we offer much. The advantage of having some definite and fairly simple mathematical formula is that there aren't then so likely to be differences of opinion as to what should be included. This bedevilled the early years of the Munros in Scotland where the secondary peaks included in the original list were not not deemed worthy of climbing by later users. Last year there was a discussion here about the Highest Hundred and what prominence it should specify. Currently it specifies 100m. This excludes many minor bumps but allows whole ranges to be represented (such as the Sperrins) which would not appear if the prominence requirement was lower. Generally this seems to me to be advantageous, though some anomalies remain such as the exclusion in this scheme of Caher and Beenkeragh.

However I fully agree that prominence, so useful for some purposes, can be a tyrant of an abstraction in some situations. One sometimes quoted example of this is that the highest col defining the prominence of Mt McKinley in Alaska is the Panama Canal! This makes little practical sense. And so it is with some interesting summits in Ireland.

So, yes I think that we should add to the summit lists that MV uses. One way of doing this is to include what in Britain would be called Humps or hills with hundred metre prominence. And it might also be desirable to allow people to nominate other candidates. We could also discuss the use of other mathematical properties, such as isolation, used in some lists elsewhere.

As always in a community like MV it is going to depend on volunteers to help prepare the lists.
Captain. My melanc.. by Bleck Cra   (Show all posts)


RECENT CONTRIBUTIONS 1 2 3 .. 19 Next page >>
Forum: General
MV Mountain Gathering 2017
Onzy a few minutes ago.
Always a great night ... all welcome.

  
Forum: General
MV Gathering & Awards
Onzy a few minutes ago.
Our biggest gathering of the year is in planning at the moment. The Irish Mountain Gathering will take place in the Lansdowne Hostel Dublin 4 on Friday, February 17th (7.30 for 8pm). As part of th...

  
Track
Knockmealdown Round - Out by the spine. Back by the belly.
GSheehy 3 hours ago.
An early start had me on Crohan West at 08:00. It was a glorious morning. This is what Bowie meant by ?serious moonli... walk, Len: 45.8km, Climb: 1968m, Area: Crohan West, Knockmealdown Mountains (I

Track
Central Dingle Quartet from Anascual
Bunsen7 5 hours ago.
walk, Len: 15.8km, Climb: 949m, Area: Stradbally Mountain, Central Dingle (Irel...

  
Summit Comment
Carnaween: The visitors book box near the summit
Aidy a day ago.
Just wanted to show the brilliantly constructed little box which contains the visitors book. It was too wet and windy on my visit to take it out and risk ruining it. A few shafts of light breaking...

  
Summit Comment
Carnaween: Bad Weather Adding Drama To Great Views
Aidy a day ago.
I used the commonly taken route from Disert Graveyard (worth a visit in its own right) over ground that was alternatively boggy or pretty steep. It was freezing cold in these parts, with a strong ...

Summit Comment
Corrin: A family stroll.
David-Guenot 5 days ago.
Climbed this hill in November 2014, with a friend who used to live in the area. Starting at the Coillte car park, we did a nice loop on the forest paths, circling around the hill in an anticlockwi...

  
Summit Comment
Luggala: Fancy View from White Hill
davsheen a week ago.
Autumn's evening view across to Luggala/Fancy from White Hill on route down from Djouce using the Wicklow Way boardwalk section.

  
Summit Comment
Binn Charrach: The peat-hag capital of Connemara
markwallace a week ago.
The descent from Benbaun to the R344 via Knockpasheemore/Binn Charrach is hard going after a day in the Bens. The Knockpasheemore ridge looks nice and flat from below, but is boggy, undulating and...

Summit Comment
Ridge of Capard: My Slieve Bloom Climb 27-11-2016
ShaunDunne a week ago.
I climbed the Ridge of Cappard on the 27-11-2016 with my Granddad.It was a fun day, but was cold and windy at the top.

  
Forum: Suggestions
System problems
simon3 4 days ago.
For the last few days we have been experiencing apparent difficulties, cause unknown.This has been manifesting itself as various parts of the system failing leading to odd screens or sometimes not...

  
Summit Comment
Mount Leinster: my Climb in Wexford & Carlow 20-11-2016
ShaunDunne a week ago.
I climbed Mount Leinster on 20-11-2016 with my GranddadI was really excited at this was my first every hill walk in the snow.It was very cold at the top, but we still stopped and had our lunch up ...


RECENT CONTRIBUTIONS 1 2 3 .. 19 Next page >>